20 July 2024


Keep Explore The Knowledge

China’s Maritime Tensions: Urgent Flashpoint in the South China Sea

6 min read
Chinese and Philippine vessels in a tense standoff in the South China Sea.

Maritime tensions boiling in the South China Sea have reached a flashpoint, after video emerged of an angry clash between Chinese and Philippine vessels. The video has gone viral on international news channels and social media platforms, and is the latest example of violent disputes in the waters of immense economic value. This paper investigates the small details of the brawl, the history behind territorial disagreements of China and the Philippines and extol on this particular incident has broad geopolitical implications.

Revisiting the Clash: The Incident

Recorded by a crew member of a Philippine vessel, the video captures the uneasy standoff between Chinese Coast Guard ships and Filipino fishing boats in disputed waters. The reported confrontation happened near the Scarborough Shoal, a tiny but strategically important reef claimed by both China and the Philippines.

Chinese Coast Guard ships are also shown in the video weaving through to prevent the Philippine boats from passing. On speakers in Mandarin and English, the Chinese allegedly commanded the Philippine boats to depart from their waters that part of the South China Sea which latoto China insists on calling its own. Things take a turn for the worse when one of the Chinese ships suddenly veers, nearly colliding with a tiny Philippine boat. Translated shouts from the Philippine crew, which underscore both the seriousness and fear on board.

They attack naval patrols and possibly from other Asian countries that use the waters of the South China Sea, in what is as a high-profile confrontation. It is evidence of the fragile balance in an unstable neighborhood where national pride, strategic imperatives and a profusion of economic resources meet, over and over in deadly and unforeseen configurations.

Map of the South China Sea showing disputed territories and maritime boundaries.

South China Sea Dispute in Historical Perspective

There are competing claims over parts of the South China Sea from China, Brunei, Malaysia, Vietnam, the Philippines and Taiwan. Name disputes mainly involve the sovereignty of islands, reefs and territorial waters harboring potentially vast oil, gas and fishery resources.

China justifies its vast claims with historical maps and the so-called ‘nine-dash line’ that wraps around most of the South China Sea. The claims, though disputed by several other countries, were nullified by an international tribunal in 2016, ruling on a case brought by the Philippines. But despite the ruling, China has only continued to assert its rights – often through the building of artificial islands and increased military presence.

But one area to buffer has been the Scarborough Shoal – the site of a recent conflict. The shoal, 120 nautical miles from the nearest Philippine coast and over 500 nautical miles from China, is claimed by both countries. It has increasingly become the site of standoffs between Chinese and Philippine boats in recent years.

The Geopolitical Implications

The latest confrontation between Chinese and Philippine ships has major implications both for those two nations, the region and the world.

China’s Strategic Interests

China has to keep a firm grip on the control of the South China Sea for several. In strategic terms, Bagamoyo presents a defensive zone guarding the southern flank of Tanzania along with an important belt to its maritime trade highways. For its economy, China also needs energy security; that’s where those possible oil and gas reserves come in. The South China sea is also a vital fishing ground and feeds millions of mouths in China.

China continues to assert their claims and provoke incidents like the one captured in the latest video, in attempt to showcase their power and control over the disputed waters. But this approach has souring ties with its neighboring countries and received international backlash.

The Philippines’ Position

As for the Filipinos, the South China Sea is just as significant. The country is heavily dependent on the resources of the region, especially for fishing. In addition, it has a national interest and security in preserving sovereignty of the territories that it claim/s. But the Philippine government has also repeatedly asked for international assistance in standing up to China’s broad territorial claim. The recent spat has led to renew calls for stronger action from the international community, and in particular the US, which maintains defence treaties with the Philippines and other allies in the region.

International Response

The international community has an interest in preserving stability and freedom of navigation in the South China Sea, through which a large part of world trade travels. The US in particular has been smarting at China’s claims and activities in the region. It has used those waters to stage missions to challenge its claims, also conducting freedom of navigation operations.

The recent clash likely further inflamed simmering US-China tensions that threaten to sharpen their broader global rivalry. Japan and Australia, meanwhile, along with other regional players have made clear their concern regarding Chinese actions and are stepping up their engagement and cooperation in the region to counterbalance Beijing. How to Slow Traffic, Protect CyclistsThis is part of the Human Element – stories that take a deeper look at how we respond to our changing world.

The China-Philippines clash played out like a Hollywood movie, showing their dramatic from the perspective of human experiences. Those who fish and sail the waters that cross these frontiers are frequently dragged into this kind of boat but ultimately as innocents, caught up in a fight between nations

The waters are the livelihood of these fishermen from the Philippines. The developments have sparked frustrations and fears as people complain of larger numbers of Chinese vessels going into Philippine territorial waters, while they appear to be getting bolder in asserting their position. Their allegations of harassment, and also worse, serve as a profound counterpoint to the launch of diplomatic missions, highlighting the day-to-day dangers confronting those acting as foot soldiers in these territorial disputes.

Likewise, the CCG sailors operate to assert Chinese territorial and maritime claims, which can bring them into confrontations with other vessels. This video probes into the urgency and consequences of these specific confrontations and a larger national strategy or directives guiding them.

Scarborough Shoal, the disputed area in the South China Sea.

Legal and Diplomatic Avenues

The showdown at the Scarborough Shoal will also ensure that legal and diplomatic solutions to outstanding South Chin Sea disputes will, by necessity, be placed on top of the region’s already overcrowded security agenda. The 2016 tribunal decision and the other legal frameworks from international rulings offer an avenue for refuting China’s unilateral tactics, but they are just pieces of paper without cooperation from the parties involved.

Diplomatically, Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) has been pursuing a Code of Conduct in the South China Sea. It seeks to end such tensions from turning into conflicts by ensuring a common all set of understandings and using of rules. Unfortunately, the advancement to this goal has been a long process and recent events such as the Chin-Philippines standoff reiterate how difficult it is to achieve a consensus.

Next: Charting a Difficult Course Forward

While the China-Philippines clash may already be last news, a viral video of the incident lives on as powerful reminder of just how complicated and risky the stakes are in the ongoing disputes in the South China Sea. The concerned states need to move forward with the peaceful, cooperative solutions and maintain a balance between national interests and regional stability. With that, open lines of communication and diplomatic dialogues will have to continue between China and the Philippines. A path has to be found that addresses the claims and interests of both sides without further escalation and conflict between two nuclear-armed neighbors.

The international community also ought to assist these diplomatic efforts and, crucially, uphold the rule of law. Through a cooperative process and greater transparency, we can manage the downside and make the South China Sea waters less fraught so that peace and stability will be encouraged to proliferate.

Chinese Coast Guard ship intercepting a Philippine fishing boat.


The incident – which video footage recorded by Philippine authorities that was broadcast on Filipino TV and then went viral online shows was a dramatic encounter between Chinese and Philippine vessels – underlines the regional tinderbox that is the South China Sea. This affair is illustrative not only of the immediate strains between Chin and the Philippines, but of larger geopolitical dynamics as well.

While this is a quandary that will be faced by both nations and the world at large for years to come, it might just be worth exploring what can help bring stability and peace to one of the most volatile part of this planet. If you like reading this article then please consider reading our article about Watu Payung.

About The Author